加州理工终于忍受不了最近几届的招生质素了

Faculty petition

January 16, 2024

Dear faculty colleagues:

Over the past few years, faculty colleagues across campus have noticed and commented on a sharp decline in the quantitative skills of our undergraduate students. In particular, although many of our undergraduates are of the same caliber as in the past, there has been a concerning drop in preparedness at the low end of the distribution. This decline has worsened with recent changes in our admissions practices, and is particularly acute for the current sophomore class. An inordinate number of students are failing courses, honor code violations are on the rise, and requests for tutors and extensions have substantially increased. Some faculty report having to adjust grading practices, as well as course content, to the change in student population.

We fear that this decline will have disastrous consequences for our students’ training and career outcomes, for Caltech’s educational mission, and for Caltech’s reputation at large.

The goal of this letter is to initiate discussion and action on this critical and urgent matter.

Below we consider possible causes for the decline. Based on these reasons, we believe that the problem requires both immediate action as well as longer term improvement and monitoring in admissions practices.

… (more here) You Can and Should Do Better, Faculty Members - A Commentary on the Reinstated SAT/ACT Requirement for Undergraduate Admissions - The California Tech

这种话由教授说出来,已经算是很严重了

22 个赞

活该

4 个赞

这话是可以公开说的吗
:troll:

5 个赞

你美唯一指定金字招牌MIT

无legacy无AA

什么HYPS根本不配的好吧

1 个赞

caltech也没有

学生回信更可笑了

You Can and Should Do Better, Faculty Members - A Commentary on the Reinstated SAT/ACT Requirement for Undergraduate Admissions

只能说巧妇难为无米之炊 :troll:

7 个赞

是啥zs

American Airlines

14 个赞

To be fair,大部分faculty的水平做科研还行教课就算了吧,还不如khan academy

11 个赞

affirmative action

7 个赞

忽略对逻辑推论不严谨的反驳,学生回信的主要论点是这一届学生是被COVID影响了才成绩差,和SAT/ACT要求无关(i.e.过两年自然就恢复正常了)。这个我信,网课一代问题很大

8 个赞

私立专门的 teaching professor 教弱智 intro 课,research professor 拉高上限我觉得挺合理的。你总能看到一个忙前忙后在 100 level 上课的老师,课件非常丰富、问答很详实,然后 700+ 的老师上课都在说上周去 DC 开会,

19 个赞

我们大公立也有 teaching stream,教得比那些只会做research的prof好多了

4 个赞

美国早晚被那些*霍霍了。

3 个赞

这其实是一个需要instructor兼容学生还是需要学生兼容instructor的问题

这些教授反了吗?是不是没经历过文革不知道厉害

如果是教学,目的是把学生教会送走毕业,那应该是前者
如果是科研,目的是产生科研成果成为学术门阀,那就是后者

2 个赞

理论上只有文理学院属于前者

啥学校课号能到700多 :jingya: 教授自己开的新课吗

1 个赞

niubi :yaoming: